A seller in Fletcher Hills says yes to $15,000 off. Most buyers hear that and take the lower price. On a lot of El Cajon deals right now, I think that's the weakest way to take the money.
Here's the math on a typical three-bedroom ranch in Fletcher Hills, the single-story 1950s and '60s homes off Navajo Road, priced around $780,000.
Say you put 20% down. Your loan is about $624,000. At a rate around 6.25%, principal and interest come to roughly $3,840 a month.
**Option one: take the $15,000 as a price cut.** Your loan drops by $12,000, because the other $3,000 would have been part of your down payment. Your payment goes down about $74 a month. You'll save a little on property tax too. It's real money, but it's small.
**Option two: take the $15,000 as a seller credit and use it to buy points.** That's about two and a half points on a $624,000 loan. With the lender pricing I've seen this fall, that takes about half a point off your rate, give or take. At 5.75%, your payment is roughly $3,640. That's about $200 a month, and it lasts the whole life of the loan.
Same $15,000 from the seller. Almost three times the monthly savings.
There's a catch. Points only pay off if you keep the loan. If rates drop a full point next year and you refinance, you've spent the seller's money on a rate you dropped after twelve months. A price cut doesn't have that problem. The lower price stays with the house.
So the question I ask buyers isn't "which saves more?" It's "how long do you honestly think you'll keep this loan?" If you can't picture refinancing within two or three years, buy the rate down. If you're sure you'll refinance soon, take the price cut and keep it simple.
One more opinion. I'm not a fan of the temporary 2-1 buydown that a lot of builders and listing agents push. It feels great in year one. Then in year three your payment lands right back at the full rate, and you're counting on a refinance that might not show up. If someone is paying for your rate, I'd rather it be permanent.
One practical note: lenders cap how much a seller can credit you, and your appraisal has to support the price. Get your lender to run both versions before you write the offer, not after the seller agrees.
If a seller is willing to give you $15,000, what would you do with it?