← Jeff Mejia

Read the Tax Bill Before the Rent Comps

Jeff Mejia · November 16, 2026

Almost every investor I talk to in Temecula comes in with rent comps. Hardly any of them come in with the tax bill. I think they've got it backwards.

Here's how it plays out. Say you're looking at a four-bedroom in Paloma del Sol listed around $650,000, and similar homes nearby rent for about $3,400 a month. That looks workable on paper. The base property tax is a little over 1%, so call it $7,000 a year. Then you pull the actual bill and find the special assessments, the Mello-Roos and other district charges that come with a lot of the newer master-planned tracts out here. Depending on the street, that can add a few thousand dollars a year.

Put $4,000 a year on top of the base tax and that's roughly $330 a month you didn't plan for. Add an HOA around $100. Now your $3,400 in rent is covering a lot more fixed cost, and you haven't replaced a single water heater yet.

It's like a restaurant that looks cheap on the menu until the check comes with all the fees added. The food didn't change. Your math did.

The part people miss is how long it lasts. Some of these bonds run for decades, and many of them go up a little every year. Rent in this area has climbed, but nobody promises it'll keep climbing on schedule. The special tax goes up whether rents do or not.

For a pure rental, I'll take the 1988 house with the dated kitchen and no special tax over the 2015 house with quartz counters and a $4,000 assessment. The older place rents for a bit less. It usually cash flows better anyway, and the kitchen is a fixable problem. The tax bill isn't.

This isn't a knock on the newer communities. If you're living in the home, those assessments paid for the parks, the schools, and the streets you'll actually use, and plenty of families think that's worth it. A tenant just won't pay you extra for them.

If you're selling in one of these tracts and your bond is close to paid off, say so in the listing. Investors who know what they're looking at will notice, and it's a real selling point most listings leave out.

Buyers, here's my one ask. Before you fall in love with a rent number, look up the property's tax bill on the Riverside County Treasurer's site and read every line. It takes five minutes, and the rent comps aren't going anywhere.