← Mark Quesada

The Cheap HOA Is the Expensive One

Mark Quesada · November 16, 2026

A listing like this crosses my desk every few weeks. It's a two-bedroom in a 1970s tower on Sheridan Road in Edgewater with a lake view, and the monthly dues are about a third lower than the building next door. The buyer sees a steal. I see a warning label.

First-time condo buyers shop the monthly number. I understand why. It sits right next to the mortgage payment, and a lower one makes the whole budget feel friendlier. But dues aren't a price. They're a decision the board made about how much to save, and a low number means they decided not to.

Chicago makes this easy to check and just as easy to ignore. Older lakefront high-rises have to deal with the city's facade inspection rules, and a building that tall and that close to the water takes a beating from wind, freeze-thaw cycles, and road salt blowing off Lake Shore Drive all winter. Concrete repair. Balcony work. Window replacement, riser pipes, elevators that were installed when Nixon was in office. None of it is optional and none of it is cheap. If the reserve fund can't cover it, the bill shows up as a special assessment split across every owner. That includes the person who bought last spring because the dues looked nice.

Before anyone writes an offer, I ask for this:

- The current reserve study, and the date it was done - Two years of board minutes - Any special assessments from the last five years, plus any being discussed - The budget, so you can see whether reserves are actually funded or just mentioned

The minutes are where the truth lives. Boards argue about money in writing. If you see "deferred until next year" in three meetings in a row, you've learned more than any listing photo will ever tell you.

Here's the part that sometimes annoys listing agents: I'd rather put a client in the building with higher dues and a healthy reserve than in the bargain next door. The higher number is the honest one. You're paying for the roof now instead of getting surprised by it later. Lenders have gotten pickier about underfunded buildings since 2021, too, and that matters the day you decide to sell.

I own a brokerage in San Diego and Chicago, and I've spent 20 years running teams and coaching high-volume agents. The pattern never changes. The buyers who get burned on condos rarely overpaid on price. They underpaid on dues and covered the difference later, with interest.

So when the dues look cheap, ask the next question. Cheap compared to what the building actually needs?